Should Charcoal Be On Fire When Grilling?

Grilling is more than a cooking method; it’s a culinary art form that has been cherished for generations. From the satisfying sound of meat sizzling as it meets the searing grates to the intoxicating aroma of smoke and char, grilling awakens the senses and brings people together.

Charcoal should not be on fire with open, roaring flames when grilling. Instead, the charcoal should be lit and allowed to burn until it reaches a state where the flames have died down and a layer of white ash forms on the surface. This is the ideal point to start grilling. Without the risk of flare-ups, the smoldering coals and white ash’s heat provide a consistent and even cooking temperature. Cooking over open flames can lead to unevenly cooked or burned food, so it’s important to wait for the flames to subside before placing your items on the grill.

How do you use a charcoal grill for beginners?

Using a charcoal grill for beginners can be straightforward with these basic steps:

  1. Gather your supplies: You’ll need charcoal, a chimney starter, grilling utensils, and safety gear.
  2. Prepare the charcoal. Fill the chimney starter with charcoal and light it. Wait until the coals are ashed over, indicating they’re ready.
  3. Set up the grill: Place the charcoal in the grill, arranging it for your desired cooking method (direct or indirect heat).
  4. Add oil to the grates: Before heating, brush the grates with cooking oil to prevent sticking.
  5. Light the charcoal: Carefully pour the hot coals into the grill. Leave the lid off and let them burn until they turn white-gray.
  6. Control heat: Adjust the air vents to control temperature. Open vents for more heat; close them for less.
  7. Preheat and clean: Put the grill lid on to preheat. Utilize a grill brush for cleaning the grates.
  8. Grill your food: Place your food on the grill and cook, turning as needed. Keep an eye on the temperature.
  9. Monitor and serve: Use a meat thermometer to check if the meat is ready. Once your food is ready, remove it from the grill and serve.
  10. Safety: Be cautious with hot coals and always follow safety precautions.

Remember, practice makes perfect. Don’t let poor initial results deter you; grilling abilities improve with practice.

How should my coals look before grilling?

Before grilling on a charcoal grill, your coals should look like they are covered with a layer of white or gray ash. This indicates that the coals are fully lit and have reached the right temperature for cooking. The coals should be glowing and have a consistent, even layer of ash, which usually takes about 20–30 minutes after lighting them in a chimney starter.

Avoid cooking over coals that are still black or have visible flames, as they can produce uneven heat and potentially impart a bitter taste to your food. Wait until the coals are burned, and you’ll have a more controlled and efficient grilling experience.

Should the grill be open or closed when starting a fire?

When starting a fire on a charcoal grill, it’s generally best to keep the grill’s lid open. Opening the lid allows for proper air circulation, which is essential for lighting the coals and getting them to the desired temperature. Here’s the typical process:

  1. Open the grill’s lid and any bottom air vents.
  2. Place your charcoal on the grill or in a chimney starter.
  3. Light the charcoal using a fire starter, a charcoal chimney, or other safe methods.
  4. Leave the lid off to allow oxygen to reach the coals and help them ignite.

Once the coals are burned and ready for grilling, you can subsequently shut the lid to preheat the grill and maintain a consistent cooking temperature. However, during the initial lighting process, keeping the lid open is essential to facilitate the ignition.

Should there be a flame when grilling with charcoal?

During charcoal grilling, it’s best to avoid having flames directly contact your food. Instead, you want the charcoal to produce a consistent, even heat for cooking. Here’s what to aim for:

  1. After lighting: Initially, you may see flames as the charcoal lights. This is normal and usually subsides as the coals ash over and reach the desired temperature. You should wait until the coals are concealed with white or gray ash prior to setting your food on the grill.
  2. During cooking: Once your coals have developed a layer of ash and are ready for grilling, there should be no visible flames directly beneath the food. Instead, you should have glowing, red-hot coals providing indirect heat. The heat source comes from the hot coals and the air circulation within the grill, not from flames.

Flames can cause uneven cooking, flare-ups, and an undesirable flavor in your dishes. If you experience excessive flames, you can utilize a spritzer of water to control them or adjust the positioning of the food to reduce direct exposure to the flames.

How long should charcoal burn before cooking?

Charcoal should burn for approximately 20–30 minutes before you start cooking. Here’s a general guideline for the process:

  1. Lighting: It takes about 10–15 minutes to light the charcoal in a chimney starter. You’ll see flames initially as the coals ignite. Wait until the coals have developed a layer of ash, meaning they have a white or grayish appearance all over the surface. This indicates they are ready for cooking.
  2. Preheating: After transferring the heated coals to the grill, allow them to burn for an additional 10-15 minutes with the grill lid on to preheat the grates. This helps ensure a consistent cooking temperature.

The total time can vary depending on factors like the variety of charcoal used, weather conditions, and the specific grill setup. It’s crucial to be patient and wait for the coals to reach the proper temperature, as this will result in more even and predictable cooking.

What color should charcoal be when it is ready?

When charcoal is prepared for cooking on a charcoal grill, it should be mostly covered with white or gray ash. The coals should have a consistent, ashy appearance. This indicates that the charcoal is fully lit and has reached the desired temperature for grilling. The red, glowing appearance of the coals beneath the ash indicates that they are hot and ready to cook your food. Avoid using charcoal that is still black or has visible flames, as this can lead to uneven cooking and potentially affect the taste of your dish.

How should grill flames look?

When grilling, the flames should be controlled, not excessive. Here’s how grill flames should typically look:

  1. Before Cooking: When initially lighting the charcoal or gas grill, you may see flames as the fuel source ignites. However, these flames should subside as the coals or burners heat up.
  2. During Cooking: Ideally, you want minimal to no visible flames directly beneath your food. The heat should come from the hot coals or burners, creating a consistent, even cooking environment. Rather than using direct flames, your food should cook using radiant heat.

Excessive or uncontrolled flames may result in sudden bursts of flames and unevenly cooked meals. To maintain a safe and pleasant grilling experience, it’s important to manage the flames. If you encounter flare-ups during grilling, you can move the food to a cooler part of the grill, reduce the fuel source (e.g., turning down the gas), or use a spritzer of water to control the flames.

Are coals supposed to stay lit?

Yes, coals on a charcoal grill are supposed to stay lit while you’re grilling. The purpose of the charcoal is to provide a steady heat source for cooking your food.

Here’s how it typically works:

  1. You light the charcoal, and it starts to burn and produce heat.
  2. The coals will ash over, meaning they will become covered in white or gray ash. This is a sign that they are fully lit and ready for grilling.
  3. Once the coals have developed a layer of ash and glowing red, you place your food on the grill grates and cook it using the heat generated by the hot coals.

During the grilling procedure, it’s important to maintain a consistent temperature by managing the air vents and the amount of charcoal used, so the coals continue to produce heat. If the coals start to go out, you might be required to add more charcoal or adjust the airflow to keep them lit.

Tips for grilling over charcoal

Here are some tips for grilling over charcoal:

  1. Use the right charcoal: Choose quality charcoal blocks or natural charcoal. Lump charcoal ignites faster and burns hotter, while briquettes are more consistent and may have additives for flavor.
  2. Ignite the charcoal properly: Use a chimney starter or electric charcoal starter for the best and safest way to light charcoal. Avoid using lighter fluid, as it can impart a chemical taste to your food.
  3. Wait for proper temperature: Wait until the coals are burned with a white or gray appearance prior to placing food on the grill. This usually takes about 20-30 minutes after lighting.
  4. Control the airflow: Adjust the air vents to control the grill’s temperature. More air means higher heat, while less air reduces the heat. Aim for a consistent temperature for even cooking.
  5. Preheat and clean the grates: Put the grill lid on to preheat the grates and utilize a grill brush to clean them. A clean grate prevents sticking and helps with sear marks.
  6. Oil the grates: Before grilling, use an oil-soaked paper towel or a brush to oil the grates to prevent sticking.
  7. Direct and indirect heat: Learn how to create zones for direct (directly over the coals) and indirect (off to the side) heat. This allows you to sear and then finish cooking your food.
  8. Flip and turn, but don’t press: Flip or turn your food as needed, but avoid pressing it with a spatula. This squeezes out flavorful juices.
  9. Invest in good tools: Get high-quality grilling utensils, like tongs, a spatula, and a meat thermometer.
  10. Keep the lid on: While cooking, keep the grill lid on for heat consistency and to infuse a smoky flavor into your food.
  11. Manage flare-ups: If you experience flare-ups from dripping fat, move the food to a cooler section of the grill or use a spray bottle of water to control the flames.
  12. Employ a meat thermometer: Invest in a meat thermometer to ensure your food is cooked to the desired level of doneness.
  13. Rest the meat: Allow grilled meat to rest for a few minutes before serving. This helps redistribute juices and ensures a juicy result.
  14. Experiment and have fun: Grilling is as much an art as it is a science. Experiment with different rubs, marinades, and cooking techniques to discover your favorite flavors.

Remember, practice makes perfect. Enjoy the process of improving as a griller and don’t let initial results discourage you.

How do you burn charcoal properly?

Burning charcoal properly is important for a successful grilling experience. Here’s how to do it:

1. Select the appropriate charcoal variety: Choose high-quality charcoal briquettes or lump charcoal. Lump charcoal is known for burning hotter and faster, while briquettes provide more consistent heat and may have additives for flavor.

2. Arrange the coals: When employing a charcoal grill, arrange the charcoal in a pyramid shape or in a single layer. Leave some space between the coals to allow for proper airflow.

3. Lighting: There are a few secure methods of igniting coal:

Chimney Starter: Place the charcoal in a chimney starter and light a newspaper or a fire starter cube underneath. The chimney starter allows for even lighting.

Electric Charcoal Starter: This tool uses electricity to light the charcoal without the necessity of lighter fluid or paper.

Avoid lighter fluid: It’s best to avoid utilizing lighter fluid as it can leave a chemical taste on your food. If you do use it, be cautious and wait for it to evaporate before lighting the coals.

4. Wait for the coal to burn: Wait for the coals to ash over, which means they should be mostly covered with white or gray ash. This usually requires about 20-30 minutes after being ignited. The coals should be glowing red when ready.

5. Spread the coals: Once the coals are burned and hot, spread them evenly in the grill, positioning them for your preferred cooking technique (direct or indirect heat).

6. Modify the air vents: Control the temperature by adjusting the air vents on the grill. Open vents for more heat and close them partially for less heat. Aim for your preferred cooking temperature.

7. Preheat and clean the grates: Put the grill lid on to preheat and utilize a grill brush to clean the grates. A clean grate helps prevent sticking.

8. Oil the grates: Prior to placing food on the grill, lightly oil the grates with a paper towel or brush to prevent sticking.

By following these steps, you’ll be able to burn charcoal properly and achieve the right temperature for successful grilling.


In the world of charcoal grilling, patience is a virtue. The answer to whether charcoal should be on fire when grilling is a resounding “no.” Instead, let the flames fade, embrace the white ash, and ignite the flavors that make charcoal grilling an art form.

Leave a Comment